RC India

RC Equipments => Batteries and Chargers => Topic started by: gbisht on March 20, 2012, 10:58:01 PM



Title: Which one is better charger for LiPo
Post by: gbisht on March 20, 2012, 10:58:01 PM
Hi All,

Which one is better charger for LiPo battery ??

Turnigy
http://www.hobbyking.com/hobbyking/store/__7028__Turnigy_Accucel_6_50W_6A_Balancer_Charger_w_accessories.html

or

Hobbyking
http://www.hobbyking.com/hobbyking/store/__11060__HobbyKing_ECO6_50W_5A_Balancer_Charger_w_accessories.html


Title: Re: Which one is better charger for LiPo
Post by: praveen on March 20, 2012, 11:13:41 PM
i would suggest, Turnigy instead of poor calibrated and plastic HK!


Title: Re: Which one is better charger for LiPo
Post by: gbisht on March 20, 2012, 11:14:59 PM
thanks parveen............any one in foram who used both...........


Title: Re: Which one is better charger for LiPo
Post by: praveen on March 20, 2012, 11:18:03 PM
my self :)


Title: Re: Which one is better charger for LiPo
Post by: gbisht on March 20, 2012, 11:52:20 PM
ok u have both or turnigy ???


Title: Re: Which one is better charger for LiPo
Post by: dst161 on March 21, 2012, 02:30:56 AM
Go for
IMAX B6: http://www.hobbyking.com/hobbyking/store/__5548__IMAX_B6_Charger_Discharger_1_6_Cells_GENUINE_.html

or IMAX B6AC: http://www.hobbyking.com/hobbyking/store/__6478__IMAX_B6_AC_Charger_Discharger_1_6_Cells_GENUINE_.html

I use IMAX B6AC


Title: Re: Which one is better charger for LiPo
Post by: gbisht on March 21, 2012, 07:39:50 AM
oh! I havr ordered Turnigy  Acucell 6 now,

Now Please help me to select power adapter.
In my house more then 10 adapters are sitting idel

from 6v to 19v but guys can u plz tell me
it want DC or AC adapter ?
and and how much mAh required ??


Title: Re: Which one is better charger for LiPo
Post by: netsecrets00 on March 21, 2012, 10:41:42 AM
You need 12V DC 5Amp adaptor minimum.

You can use laptop adaptor if you are having with you.


Title: Re: Which one is better charger for LiPo
Post by: gbisht on March 21, 2012, 11:20:56 AM
I Am not sure about mah but my laptop charger output is 19 v as much as I remember, need to confirm once.


Title: Re: Which one is better charger for LiPo
Post by: praveen on March 21, 2012, 12:05:46 PM
no you can't use 19v ,anything between 11 to 13V is good. i suggest use 300watt SMPS used for normal PC's can be converted easily to basic 5V and 12V power supplies!
or else search for
Universal laptop Adapter which has a output of 11v to 19v (selectable) and 60 watt! hope this helps!


Title: Re: Which one is better charger for LiPo
Post by: gbisht on March 31, 2012, 03:05:51 AM
Hi Today I have received Turnigy Accucell 6 Charger

So I started searching adapters in my scrap, So I found 12v 1.25A Adapter (Maximum)

So started to charge my
NiMH battry 6v 1500mAh
then I charged
LiPo battery 7.2v 800mAh
LiPo battery 7.2v 1200mAh

and then I come to my 3cell battries
So I start charging LiPo11.1v 2200mAh, but when I hit start button, charger going to restart.
May be my adapter is not generating enough current, mAh

My question is Why I cant use 19v ?????
what if when I charge 6cell 6*3.1 = 18.6v  ??? will 12v adapter is enough to charge 6cell ??

and I heared we can connect it to car battry, when I purchased car battery, shopkeeper said we have two battries, 1 is 32A and another is 35A

so how this charger is able to handel high current ??? theny why not volts ??

Sooo confused ...............


Title: Re: Which one is better charger for LiPo
Post by: gbisht on March 31, 2012, 03:38:43 AM
How huch Normally we can charge 1 LiPo Cell........it is 3.1v each cell

but charger not stoping so I stoped on 8v (2Cell)....mean 4v Each cell

Is it ok ?? or I need to discharge it ASAP ??


Title: Re: Which one is better charger for LiPo
Post by: spitfire on March 31, 2012, 03:52:00 AM
Full charged single cell lipo will give 4.2 volts. So full charged 2 cell lipo will give you 8.4 volts.
Full discharged single cell lipo will give 3.3 volts. So never pull out of single cell lipo beyond 3.3 volts.


Title: Re: Which one is better charger for LiPo
Post by: Swapnil on March 31, 2012, 09:46:15 AM
My question is Why I cant use 19v ?????
what if when I charge 6cell 6*3.1 = 18.6v  ??? will 12v adapter is enough to charge 6cell ??

and I heared we can connect it to car battry, when I purchased car battery, shopkeeper said we have two battries, 1 is 32A and another is 35A
so how this charger is able to handel high current ??? theny why not volts ??

Firstly, the input voltage rating is 12V to 17V. So you can't exceed that. If the supply voltage lies between the given limits then all you need to check is the proper current (wattage).

A car battery with 30 A rating won't supply more current than required by the charger (5 to 6 A).
The amp rating only tells you the maximum current the battery can provide. It doesn't mean it will always give 30 A to everything.   

The charger can't take high voltage (>17V) because its internal circuitry can handle that much only.


Title: Re: Which one is better charger for LiPo
Post by: gbisht on April 01, 2012, 12:30:27 AM
Thanks swapnil,

I think I got my answer,

I am not able to find 12v~15v charger =>3A
can you tell me any LHS where I can get in cheap price ??


Title: Re: Which one is better charger for LiPo
Post by: Swapnil on April 01, 2012, 12:50:16 AM
You can get it at any local electronics shop. It'll cost you more than Rs. 400 for a good one.


Title: Re: Which one is better charger for LiPo
Post by: gbisht on April 01, 2012, 12:51:58 AM
can I go to Laptop charger shop ???


Title: Re: Which one is better charger for LiPo
Post by: aviator on April 01, 2012, 01:52:55 AM
Go here and buy this..
http://www.ebay.in/itm/ENTER-Universal-Charger-Adapter-Laptop-90W-USB-PORT-/160584495827?pt=LH_DefaultDomain_203&hash=item256394f2d3
or this one
http://www.ebay.in/itm/Universal-Laptop-Power-Charger-8-Connectors-AC-110V-240V-DC-12V-24V-/270940891223?pt=LH_DefaultDomain_203&hash=item3f1555e857


Title: Re: Which one is better charger for LiPo
Post by: gbisht on April 01, 2012, 02:06:27 AM
Hi Aviator,

Have you bought any of them ??


Title: Re: Which one is better charger for LiPo
Post by: aviator on April 01, 2012, 02:37:14 AM
Yup... the first one.. have bn using it with my accucel 6!!!


Title: Re: Which one is better charger for LiPo
Post by: gbisht on April 01, 2012, 03:08:50 AM
ENTER brand....I am looking cheapter one.....Today I will go to my local computer market and find that ENTER brand charger, as I know I'll get it on less price comparitively to ebay


Title: Turnigy Accucel-6 Burnt
Post by: gbisht on April 03, 2012, 12:31:38 AM
Hello All,

It is just 3rd day of arrival of my Turnigy Accucel 6 Blance Charger and I burnt it in Morning

I was trying to charge 3S Lipo 2200 mAh but I have power adapte of 12v 1000mAh rating so it was unable to give enough power to Charger and charger turn off it self.

Then I look my creative home theater Adapter, it is 13.5v 5000mAh, So this charger can support 12v~15v & 5A

So I pluged in hurry and that become my big mistake  :banghead:, That adapter is AC/AC adapter but this charger required DC input  :banghead:

So I smell some wounderfull burning component and a little magical sound.....tik

and everything goes blank................... :-\


Then I opened it and try to figure out what I have burnt and I didnt found any component burnt or any mark, so I put DC input and it flash its LCD once and then turn off. and till that time it is dead.

Can anyone help me ......... :help: :help:


Title: Re: Which one is better charger for LiPo
Post by: gbisht on April 03, 2012, 01:09:42 AM
Ok, so here it is,

I burnt a IC as shown and marked in image.

Do any one have his faulty charger and like to donate its charger that particular IC  :help: :help:???

I am not sure but may be it will work  :headscratch:


Title: Re: Which one is better charger for LiPo
Post by: rastsaurabh on April 03, 2012, 01:14:06 AM
how did you conclude that this particular IC gone bad??


Title: Re: Which one is better charger for LiPo
Post by: gbisht on April 03, 2012, 01:20:51 AM
I have seen a crack on IC which is not clear in pic.....

its very light line just like scratch


Title: Re: Which one is better charger for LiPo
Post by: Swapnil on April 03, 2012, 07:49:46 AM
Are there any burn marks on other components and PCB tracks?


Title: Re: Which one is better charger for LiPo
Post by: jitender on April 03, 2012, 08:27:18 AM
Yes sure I will help.


Jitender


Title: Re: Which one is better charger for LiPo
Post by: shauviks on April 03, 2012, 08:29:37 AM
Wats the icnumber??? Vcall me at 8093864974


Title: Re: Which one is better charger for LiPo
Post by: jitender on April 03, 2012, 08:33:38 AM
First step is to identify the part. ??? :headscratch:
It is not an IC.
The component in pic  is a N channel MOSFET transistor in SO-8 packing.

pins 5,6,7,8= D        Left hand side ,Connected to +ve
pin 4= G                 upper right hand
pins 1,2,3= S          lower right hand

If it has a crack then for sure damaged.
Most probably a part of the DC-DC converter stage of the charger.

Jitender


Title: Re: Which one is better charger for LiPo
Post by: gbisht on April 03, 2012, 11:16:01 AM
Sorry for Late Response

Swapnil : There is a crack in that chip.
Jitender : Thanks
Shauviks : IC No. is 6680 (Delta Symbol) 1L3H
Jitender : What should I do now ?? Can I get this Mosfet in local electronics shop ?? any substitute of it ?



Title: Re: Which one is better charger for LiPo
Post by: gbisht on April 04, 2012, 12:49:17 AM
Any one like to give his suggestion or solution ??

Shauviks : Definetly I'll call you tomorrow


Title: Re: Which one is better charger for LiPo
Post by: jitender on April 04, 2012, 08:23:37 PM
the solution is simple. 1st try to find this mosfet, if available change it, if not then look for substitute . I have not had time to look at the specifications of this device , hence can not comment on a substitute. But I am sure a sub will be available as where it is placed in the circuit matching the specs should not be critical.

jitender


Title: Re: Which one is better charger for LiPo
Post by: KALYANPRODHAN on April 04, 2012, 10:46:19 PM
Firstly, dont Panic, It must be repairable if it is not the microcontroller or the display.
Trace the Power circuit first. It may be a back preventive diode like thing that may blow the fuse (Zero resistances) or may become short.

Check
http://html.alldatasheet.com/html-pdf/51505/FAIRCHILD/FDS6680/406/1/FDS6680.html
Try IRFz44 (More Powerfull) though RDS is higher, but no problem if starts.

First make sure about the microcontriller circuit and check the digital positive rail and negative rail.
Then the sensing resistances (for cell voltage and currents) if any

And checking the uC voltage range of operation, have to check the controller ckt is OK or not (with separate 5V supply).

And, of course, first open up the large electrolytic capacitoirs and test if become Short.
Then the power high speed diodes in the Power incoming circuit so that track wont burn ups.

Please keep in mind that nothing is impossible. But have to check economical or not !

Good Luck.


Title: Re: Which one is better charger for LiPo
Post by: gbisht on April 05, 2012, 01:04:51 AM
Hello Kalyan Ji,

I dont have any electronics background, so I only undertand is I can test it by changing FDS6680

Rest is alien language for me.......can you help me buy telling me in brief (with images if possible)

Thanks


Title: Re: Which one is better charger for LiPo
Post by: KALYANPRODHAN on April 05, 2012, 06:56:49 AM
Electronics needs patience, nothing else. (book reading also have the same key ;D )
If you get the same,FDS6680, you can replace, but have to check before replace that it will not blow again for short circuit in another place.

In most circuit, large electrolytic capacitors (cylinders) connected with positive and negative supply to smooth voltage fluctuation and they are sensitive in voltage reversal (We call it polar device i. e. we have to connect in correct polarity to get best, and can ruin in reverse polarity.). So, they are to be checked before replacing the MOS. And, they have to open up (or de-solder from PCB) to check their health. Most time, they shorts internally and blows the diodes (here inside MOS) . So, you need to check and if require, replace the capacitors too.

And, look at the PIN Configuration of IRFz44 (3Pin MOS) and FDS6800. The only difference is that FDS6800 have source and drain with multiple pins. In case of scarcity of FDS6800, you can short those pins(ources together, drain together and gates together, not all together) and may connect similar MOS. the differance in resistance will generate more heat, but it have a larger capacity and above all good heatsink.

Thanks


Title: Re: Which one is better charger for LiPo
Post by: jitender on April 05, 2012, 07:20:15 AM
First step is to identify the part. ??? :headscratch:
It is not an IC.
The component in pic  is a N channel MOSFET transistor in SO-8 packing.

pins 5,6,7,8= D        Left hand side ,Connected to +ve
pin 4= G                 upper right hand
pins 1,2,3= S          lower right hand

If it has a crack then for sure damaged.
Most probably a part of the DC-DC converter stage of the charger.

Jitender

Damaged Component identification most imp part---in this case DONE
Second find the part --- in this case DONE 
http://in.rsdelivers.com/product/fairchild-semiconductor/fds6680a/trans-mosfet-n-ch-30v-125a-8-pin-soic/6710605.aspx

Now just order and replace it.But make sore u orient the dot at the corner of the package.

Send a pic of the reverse side, lets have look at it to see what is there.

Jitender


Title: Re: Which one is better charger for LiPo
Post by: gbisht on April 05, 2012, 09:06:34 AM

Send a pic of the reverse side, lets have look at it to see what is there.


Hi,

There is nothing on back side, I mean pins are only solder on top and not going in back side.

I also have done some testing may be it is usefull to identify,

I gave 15v power in curcuit, and test on multimeter,
Red Spot : Where I connect +ve wire of Multimeter
Black Spot: Where I connect -ve wire of Multimeter

and mention how much voltage I am getting on those pins

pins 5,6,7,8= D        15v
pin 4= G                 15v
pins 1,2,3= S          2.8v on Each


Title: Re: Which one is better charger for LiPo
Post by: gbisht on April 06, 2012, 07:55:33 PM
Jitender Sir,

Uploading pics of back side as you asked in PM

Also pic of crack MOSFET, and Yes DOT is also clearly visible on Mosfet for polarity

and Finally I find another same MOSFET on board, near to Output side


Title: Re: Which one is better charger for LiPo
Post by: KALYANPRODHAN on April 06, 2012, 08:22:54 PM
Source to drain voltage shows high voltage drop for high impedance of MOS.
But try to trace voltage regulator like TL431 and with it's feedback resistance, you will get  the required voltage at MOS Drain/source fed to the internal rail.

And please open the capacitors and check.
whats about the current during this testing ?


Title: Re: Which one is better charger for LiPo
Post by: gbisht on April 06, 2012, 08:44:49 PM
Kalyan Ji,

I am hardly able to understand, what are you saying because as I said i am not form Electronics Background,

I only repair my electronics on component based, not by deep electrnics,

Even I dont have resistance meter ......

can you tell me all these steps in easy language ??


Title: Re: Which one is better charger for LiPo
Post by: KALYANPRODHAN on April 07, 2012, 12:13:48 AM
GBISHT,
as you replace component basis, after searching fault, you have pation to electronics and more dedicated than 50% of electronics engineers I have seen. Please buy Albert Paul Malvino's "Electronics Principles" specially 3rd Edition if available and keep as reference (cost hardly 300Rs). Your scattered electronics knowledge will get the base and will make TajMahal, believe me. And dont regular study (at least i cannot) just start any transistor biasing chapter and along with designs, you will addicted to it.

Generally, the damaged MOS was working as switching device and not as linear voltage regulator but as switching voltage regulator.
This switch on-off ratio depend the output voltage without power loss (as switch have no power loss). This is called as switching regulator. Now there is a feedback which controls this ratio depending upon the output voltage. If the output goes high (sensed by Tl431 or similar) it stops the transistor gate trigger so that it wont become on and output become low, and when goes just below the level, it again makes off.
TL431 or similar IC goes on beyond a particular voltage. But higher voltage can be achieved connecting the IC to the fraction of desired output voltage equivalent to IC's voltage. This is done by Resistor devider circuit.
So, if you get the voltage divider resistance voltage and the IC sensor IC model/voltage you will know the DC rail voltage that was supplied by the burnt MOS.
So, give the rail direct DC voltage at that voltage or little bit low and check if the digital circuit (Display etc.) OK or not) Else total labout will go wastage.
If no, then search for more fault. Look only electrolytic capacitors damage rate is the maximum and you have to check them first.
Or if the DC voltage seems the entire circuit is OK, then just replace the MOS and make total working as you have check the rest.

Hope I can explain as simple as I can.
Better take help from any electronics friend who is interested in HOBBY Electronics too. Because circuit analysis and circuit separation is the main thing here.
Thanks


Title: Re: Which one is better charger for LiPo
Post by: jitender on April 07, 2012, 01:39:34 AM
(...........and mention how much voltage I am getting on those pins

pins 5,6,7,8= D        15v
pin 4= G                 15v
pins 1,2,3= S          2.8v on Each
[/quote].................)

When MOSFETS fail they often go short-circuit drain-to-gate.
So you will get same v reading on D and G.



Title: Re: Which one is better charger for LiPo
Post by: gbisht on April 07, 2012, 01:50:45 AM
Thanks Kalyan Sir,

As of Now I am really very busy of reading some other books which are more important for me now, but surely I marked that book and read it after finish my existing reading material.

OK So what I understand Is this MOSFET give power to circuit in controlable fasion, and save circuit for high and low voltage......

As you said, (May be I understand wrong), I have to shot the circuit and have to buypass the MOSFET.....

So I did same I connect Pin4 (G) with Pin1,2,2(S) together but it didnt work,
Today I also bough capacitor which is near to MOSFET so I changed it with same value and then tryed same thing.....

and waallaaaaaa {:)},  This charger is geting alive again.......wow :o :o

So I think after replacing this MOSFET (which I have already ordered) that charger will work again  :giggle:

Attaching Pic for refrence, also made video but it is 180 deg oppt..


Title: Re: Which one is better charger for LiPo
Post by: gbisht on April 07, 2012, 01:56:34 AM
Can I use it without this MOSFET ??? I know silly Question ........

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=weI4clSJUz0


Title: Re: Which one is better charger for LiPo
Post by: jitender on April 07, 2012, 07:07:40 AM
I dont advise you to use the charger yet. Better wait for the mosfet to arrive. Do not hurry.


Title: Re: Which one is better charger for LiPo
Post by: gbisht on April 07, 2012, 10:41:58 AM
Jitender Sir

Now I m not using it and wating for component.
It will take 7-8 working days


Title: Re: Which one is better charger for LiPo
Post by: KALYANPRODHAN on April 07, 2012, 10:34:37 PM
Oh, Nice to see it's working.
So, you are not any way behind than a normal electronics engineer.

Look, Capacitors are most problem giving device. Same thing happens to Computer Motherboards too. And sometimes, running with faulty capacitor damagr FETs also.

And I recomend you to replace the Capacitor with higher voltage level capacitor to be in safe side if space available. You have replaced with 85OC Capacitor. But use 105OC Capacitor. (though your capacitor have higher ESR, but life is higher, but it may arise problem later.
You can also make parallel an .1uF disc capacitor parallel to it to lower ESR.

Thanks


Title: Re: Which one is better charger for LiPo
Post by: gbisht on April 07, 2012, 11:44:33 PM
Thanks, But I am Computer Engineer......and very far from Electronics Engineer.....hahahaha

But this hobby is pushing me to do these things.......

no Problem, now I have spare capacitor of same value, so ready for it..

also wating for MOSFET, probably it will take atleast 10 Days to reach me.

So lets wait together and see how much sucess we will get in this...


Title: Re: Which one is better charger for LiPo
Post by: gbisht on April 18, 2012, 02:38:43 PM
Hi Everyone,

Again an Achivement  :hatsoff: , today I received replacement of faulty MOSFET  and without wasting time I went to Mobile shope and replaced faulty one.

And now it is working, not charged battery yet, but I hope it will wrok fine

Pics after replacement of MOSFET.

I like to Thanks Jitender Ji and Kalyan Ji for their Expert Advices, +1 for both

Thanks a Lot


Title: Re: Which one is better charger for LiPo
Post by: KALYANPRODHAN on April 19, 2012, 02:05:50 AM
Oh, really feel HAPPY.
It's the winning of our forum RCINDIA - RCing with open mind.
LONG LIVE RCINDIA.


Title: Re: Which one is better charger for LiPo
Post by: gbisht on April 19, 2012, 02:13:57 AM
yes very true, and now I have my own 2 issue log
1. Repaired Turnigy Tx
2. Repaired Turnigy Accucel 6

and was almost imposible without power or RCIndia and RCen support.

RCIndia Jai Ho.....