RC India

RC Equipments => Fuel and Engines => Topic started by: shadman_alam on March 28, 2011, 08:09:14 AM



Title: OS fl70 shuts down in mid air
Post by: shadman_alam on March 28, 2011, 08:09:14 AM
Recently i got a irshad's low winger with OS fl70 installed on it. I m totally new to 4 stroke engines.
We tried flying it last sunday,but the plane wouldnt take off . The engine goes down right after the launch (oh yes we hand launched a 46 size plane  ;) coz the land is hoskote is bad).
Though the engine behaved perfectly when we had the ground tests,it turns into a dead stick the moment we launch it.
we checked the tubes,and the glow, everything seems to be fine. If there is any special care to taken with this engine please let me know ppl.


Title: Re: OS fl70 shuts down in mid air
Post by: anwar on March 28, 2011, 10:08:22 AM
Though the engine behaved perfectly when we had the ground tests,it turns into a dead stick the moment we launch it.

Have you tried tilting the plane nose up and in other orientations on the ground with different throttle ranges ?  Have you tried sudden acceleration (throttle input) etc also on the ground ?


Title: Re: OS fl70 shuts down in mid air
Post by: sushil_anand on March 28, 2011, 12:25:48 PM

Though the engine behaved perfectly when we had the ground tests,it turns into a dead stick the moment we launch it.
we checked the tubes,and the glow, everything seems to be fine. If there is any special care to taken with this engine please let me know ppl.

Check the "klunk" inside the tank. Looks it's come off the tubing.

4C engines have very good suction and are less critical of plumbing. No special precautions needed.


Title: Re: OS fl70 shuts down in mid air
Post by: flyingboxcar on March 28, 2011, 06:25:19 PM
Try richening the HSN 1/4 turn and go through the motion of launching (do not release the model) if the engine behaves you are good to go.
From what you describe, it looks like you are at dead peak and the accelaration and unloading of prop combined further lean it out leading the engine to quit.
Since this is your first 4 stroke, do not try to tune for screaming 2T sound, the best way to tune  a 4T is with a tacho in the best power band for the particular engine.
Also what fuel are you using? I had the very same engine where I saw a sea change between castor based fuel and synth. Ever since I have never used castor mix on my 4T.
To add on to what Sushil says, even though the clunk may not be coming off, you need to check for following if the step at the begining of my post does not work
1. Does the clunk have a slot cut at the end apart from the hole? If not replace the clunk with a proper one.
2. Your clunk should be free in the tank, about 5-6 mm away from the end wall of the tank, this ensures that the slight elongation of tube while accelartion of the model does not lead to the clunk touching the tank end wall and stopping the fuel feed. For this very reason the slot in required at the clunk end.
Do let us know if you are able to solve your problems  


Title: Re: OS fl70 shuts down in mid air
Post by: bmanoj2 on March 28, 2011, 06:47:39 PM
Please also check RX Battery. Futaba and some other brand do have a safety feature that shuts the throttle if the Rx battery is not performing. you will get a ded engine almost 30 to 40 seconds after launch.


Title: Re: OS fl70 shuts down in mid air
Post by: flyingboxcar on March 28, 2011, 07:44:39 PM
The suggestion from Manoj makes sense if you have enabled the throttle failsafe on your radio


Title: Re: OS fl70 shuts down in mid air
Post by: shadman_alam on March 29, 2011, 02:05:17 AM
thanks for the response ppl... we will do a proper scrutiny of the engine tomorrow.. we are using synthetic oil 20% with 10 nitro% on this engine.. i think i m doing justice to the machine... not using gummy castor..... :-[  we are even planning to use a t-nipple in the pressure feed to the fuel tank..to boost the fuel pressure..  i will let you know how it turns out..

regards
shadman


Title: Re: OS fl70 shuts down in mid air
Post by: sushil_anand on March 29, 2011, 11:14:12 AM
I have been using ONLY 4C engines for over 20 years and would like to repeat what I said earlier. They have very good suction and are fairly uncritical of feed. In fact, Laser Engines advise AGAINST use of pressure! And they have a logical explanation for that.

BTW, how do use a T nipple for additional pressure?


Title: Re: OS fl70 shuts down in mid air
Post by: flyingboxcar on March 29, 2011, 01:20:10 PM
Sushil,
The FL 70 has two nipples on the muffler, may be Shadman was planning to use the other one as well to add third line for pressure to the tank .

Shadman,
Please refer the manual for FL 70 you do not need additional pressure .
I have posted the link, please refer to page 19 for correct plumbing
 http://manuals.hobbico.com/osm/fl-70-manual.pdf


Title: Re: OS fl70 shuts down in mid air
Post by: sushil_anand on March 29, 2011, 02:07:23 PM
The second one is used to connect to the crankcase breather. I have added one to most of my engine mufflers - but at the exhaust end - as it keeps the oil out of the way.

To repeat, I have NEVER felt the need for any additional pressure when flying in any attitude.



Title: Re: OS fl70 shuts down in mid air
Post by: shadman_alam on March 29, 2011, 04:59:41 PM
the muffler of OS fl70 has only one nipple.. so i m planning to connect one end of t-tube to the muffler and both the other ends to the fuel tank .. i m not using the crank pressure at all.. the configuration look similar to this ..


Title: Re: OS fl70 shuts down in mid air
Post by: flyingboxcar on March 29, 2011, 06:52:21 PM
If it looks similar to the picture above then your muffler should have two nipples.  Or it could be that the muffler supplied to you is not the original FL 70 muffler.
On other hand what are you planning to do with the third end of the tube? If you are just going to balnk it off, why use a T at all? Connect the pressure tap on muffler direct to the pressure feed of the tank and have the third line blanked off for filling.
Anyway before doing all this, just try richening the HSN 1/4 turn and check that should solve your problem. Since you are new to 4T, my guess is you have tuned it by the ear similar to a 2T engine which means it is at the peak on ground and the launch/unloading of prop is taking the engine over the peak
 


Title: Re: OS fl70 shuts down in mid air
Post by: shadman_alam on March 29, 2011, 08:39:22 PM
k.. i try tuning it with a tacho .. i ll keep u updated ..


Title: Re: OS fl70 shuts down in mid air
Post by: shadman_alam on April 05, 2011, 10:05:35 AM
we tried the process again yesterday... it dint work out again... engine shuts down when nose is down....  :banghead: :banghead: :banghead: :banghead: :banghead: :banghead: :banghead: :banghead: :banghead: :banghead:


Title: Re: OS fl70 shuts down in mid air
Post by: anwar on April 05, 2011, 10:13:01 AM
What did you mean by "the process" ?  Did you do step by step investigations, including checking the clunk line ?


Title: Re: OS fl70 shuts down in mid air
Post by: ujjwaana on April 05, 2011, 10:33:56 AM
we tried the process again yesterday... it dint work out again... engine shuts down when nose is down.... 

I am redying one small Tank for my AMP Master. Bring it to my place some time and we would try it (I also bought a 7Ah Lead Acid (SLA) battery for my NAS, which I can use for the starter.


Title: Re: OS fl70 shuts down in mid air
Post by: flyingboxcar on April 05, 2011, 12:56:21 PM
Earlier it was shutting down when launched i.e when climbing. Now it shuts down when nose is dipped. If you just richened the HSN the sweet point is somewhere in between your two settings. This is provided you have not fiddleed with anything else.
As indicated by Anwar, what did you do ? In order to trouble shoot you will have to eleminate each suspect one by one, if you do too many changes all at once you would not know what is wrong or what was correct 


Title: Re: OS fl70 shuts down in mid air
Post by: Akshayb on April 05, 2011, 09:55:16 PM
Hi Shadman,
                  I found these PDF files on OS site for this engine.

http://www.os-engines.co.jp/english/2004autumn/2004spring/pdf/mfl70_e.pdf

http://www.os-engines.co.jp/english/2004autumn/2004spring/pdf/evfl70_e.pdf

Hope this will help you.


Title: Re: OS fl70 shuts down in mid air
Post by: flyingboxcar on April 05, 2011, 10:16:29 PM
Akshay, the manual's link was already posted at  #8 . But good to see your eagerness to help.  


Title: Re: OS fl70 shuts down in mid air
Post by: Akshayb on April 05, 2011, 11:05:28 PM
Ok I didn't see that, any ways, one more link for blown engine parts.

Thanks for pointing out.


Title: Re: OS fl70 shuts down in mid air
Post by: sushil_anand on April 06, 2011, 12:26:41 PM
Also, Akshay, it doesn't appear to be a faulty engine but a fuel feed problem.

Shadman, have you checked the clunk as yet?


Title: Re: OS fl70 shuts down in mid air
Post by: Akshayb on April 06, 2011, 01:14:28 PM
That's true Sushil_Anand , I have seen this engine and with my little experience with Automobiles. I  also suggested him to check his fuel supply. As engine is starting fine, but running is a trouble.



Title: Re: OS fl70 shuts down in mid air
Post by: shadman_alam on April 06, 2011, 09:45:59 PM
ok initially there was no compression seen while rotating the prop.. so we opened the head.. we found the exhaust valve was too tight.. so we did a half turn on the exhaust valve nut to achieve perfect compression... now the main problems are:
1) the engine isnt tuning properly at the low end.. (shuts down if throttle is down)
2) engine shuts down when we launch the plane..
3) the latest problem ,the engine shuts down when nose is down

we have scrutinized the clunk and the pressure feed properly.. still cant figure what to with this..
i m planning to take to adarsh.. lets see..


Title: Re: OS fl70 shuts down in mid air
Post by: flyingboxcar on May 20, 2011, 06:57:31 PM
We would love to find out what was the problem!


Title: Re: OS fl70 shuts down in mid air
Post by: rcpilotacro on May 20, 2011, 08:08:21 PM
Alam

My 4S fuel config, you could try, rarely this config has given me problem. 70 meth 15 Synth 10 nitro 05 castor. try it


Title: Re: OS fl70 shuts down in mid air
Post by: sushil_anand on May 21, 2011, 01:08:19 PM
And mine: Methanol 80%, Nitro 7%, Klotz 13%. NEVER had a problem.


Title: Re: OS fl70 shuts down in mid air
Post by: shadman_alam on May 21, 2011, 03:16:27 PM
i had some 7 flights now on this engine now.. well the problem wasnt any fuel or tubing... it was the tuning.. the air bleed screw wasnt tuned properly.. well with help of some senior flyer at the field, i got it tuned... could anyone please tell me from could i get synthetic oil and nitro ... (ie incase i want to prepare the fuel on my own) ?????????


Title: Re: OS fl70 shuts down in mid air
Post by: sushil_anand on May 21, 2011, 05:00:22 PM
In that case, I feel you had not described your symptoms correctly. The idle mixture setting will affect mid throttle, and more important, the transition from low to high. This will manifest itself even on the ground. The airplane does not have to be airborne.

If the idle mixture is rich, the engine will splutter and then pick up when the throttle is opened rapidly. If it is lean, it will tend to cut. Do note that the high speed setting will affect the idle but not vice versa. So set the high end BEFORE setting idle. Once set you will not need to change unless you alter your fuel blend.

From my experience, it is amazing how little attention one gives to getting this right. I have resolved many "dead stick" at mid throttle by careful adjustment as described.

Anyway, the good thing is that your problem has been sorted out. Happy flying!

And yes. Klotz is available occasionally from Rajiv Jain, Radical Works, New Delhi @  :Rs:1,000+taxes+shipping for One Quart, which is just under 1 lt. Nitro should be available locally.