RC India

RC Models => Multirotors => Topic started by: merin_83 on November 08, 2016, 02:05:20 PM



Title: New Martian220 build - YAW/GYRO issues
Post by: merin_83 on November 08, 2016, 02:05:20 PM
hello guys,
               Yesterday I completed my new build with martian220 frame, details below.


FRAME : Martian 220
FC       : X RACER 3.1 (SPI)
ESC     : XS30A - Blheli DYS
MOTOR : COBRA CP 2205 2300KV
PROPS: DALPROPS 5045X3 V2
PDB     : dual bec pdb
VTX,MINIM MICRO OSD, HS1177
PIDS: left at default - using multishot 8K/2K

The ISSUE is that yaw seems to be twitchy, i tried many PIDS but dint seem to work, I did save the black box for the troubleshooting. So while the test all i do is arm the quad, change to acro, just lift off minimal or no inputs on pitch/roll and yaw and then land. But if you see the yaw gyro seems to think its yawing . And the motor was bit warm on higer side after just <1 min test. Attached the DBLACKBOX log file. The gyro is not doing it on the other axis.And from log i can see the motor speed is very much varying due to the yaw gyro. Can you please help in find whats the issue? Or is it a faulty gyro ?  ??? ???

Black Box link - https://drive.google.com/open?id=0B_xCImR-u7L4cnFQUE1WRm1OdE0 (https://drive.google.com/open?id=0B_xCImR-u7L4cnFQUE1WRm1OdE0)

@satyagupta ,@vibranthobbies, @Himadri Roy, @Sagnik, @bhaveshsangani

thanks



Title: Re: New Martian220 build - YAW/GYRO issues
Post by: Gulzaar on November 08, 2016, 02:30:04 PM
What do you mean twitchy? Does it yaw by itself? Have you set board orientation correctly in BF?


Title: Re:
Post by: merin_83 on November 08, 2016, 02:35:23 PM
Yes it clicks very small angle in yaw axis...  And after less than a minute flight..  Motors considerably warm..  Yes orientation is correct... If you see motor in black box it's varying much

Sent from my Redmi Note 3 using Tapatalk


Title: Re: New Martian220 build - YAW/GYRO issues
Post by: Swapnil on November 08, 2016, 05:06:40 PM
...  And after less than a minute flight..  Motors considerably warm..
...

That could be because those motors draw close to 20A with 5x4.5x3 props.

I'd like to build a similar quad. What is the total weight of your setup?


Title: Re: New Martian220 build - YAW/GYRO issues
Post by: merin_83 on November 08, 2016, 05:14:02 PM
...  And after less than a minute flight..  Motors considerably warm..
...

That could be because the motors draw close to 20A with 5x4.5x3 props. I'd like to build a similar quad. What is the total weight of your setup?

yes that could be one reason for the heat, but if you see the blackbox log, the motor is constantly fluctuating values, my other quads used to be more or less stable if i was just hovering with no other inputs.

And i was just hovering inside room, 2-3 ft high. So it definetly wont be drawing that much amps.


Title: Re: New Martian220 build - YAW/GYRO issues
Post by: Swapnil on November 08, 2016, 05:20:54 PM
Oh, okay. The pictures you posted are very blurry, I couldn't read anything.

I'll be building my first 250 soon. Which LiPo are you using and what is the AUW of this setup?


Title: Re: New Martian220 build - YAW/GYRO issues
Post by: merin_83 on November 08, 2016, 05:30:33 PM
AUW is 561g with 4s lipo, its the bonka 1300mah 75c lipo. Have attached a new photo of quad in 1st post.


Title: Re: New Martian220 build - YAW/GYRO issues
Post by: Swapnil on November 08, 2016, 05:48:10 PM
The prop data chart for those motors shows a max. draw of 19.52A with 5x4.5 props on 4s. Isn't it a bit risky with 5x4.5x3? Wouldn't the motors easily cross the max. allowed Amp rating during, say, a thrust punch?


Title: Re: New Martian220 build - YAW/GYRO issues
Post by: ashimda on November 08, 2016, 06:39:42 PM
Just curious, what radio are you using?

Ashim.


Title: Re: New Martian220 build - YAW/GYRO issues
Post by: pravesh736 on November 08, 2016, 07:05:04 PM
Soft mount ur fc, yaw twitch is also due to improper powersupply so check ur 5v line or add an lc filter.


Title: Re: New Martian220 build - YAW/GYRO issues
Post by: merin_83 on November 08, 2016, 07:43:23 PM
Soft mount ur fc, yaw twitch is also due to improper powersupply so check ur 5v line or add an lc filter.


yeah, will try a different bec and see, also planning to remount the FC, as this martian had one more tray above FC so we can mount rx ....


Title: Re: New Martian220 build - YAW/GYRO issues
Post by: merin_83 on November 08, 2016, 07:51:12 PM
Just curious, what radio are you using?

Ashim.

9xr pro with frsky djt module, i have set deadband to 15 on yaw and 5 on other channel.


Title: Re: New Martian220 build - YAW/GYRO issues
Post by: merin_83 on November 08, 2016, 08:15:36 PM
The prop data chart for those motors shows a max. draw of 19.52A with 5x4.5 props on 4s. Isn't it a bit risky with 5x4.5x3? Wouldn't the motors easily cross the max. allowed Amp rating during, say, a thrust punch?
[/quoti dont think its 19,,,
here is the chart

100%   Thrust (g)      Current (A)   
Prop Tested:   Max(g)   Avg Max(g)*   Max (A)   Avg Max(A)*

HQProp 5x4x3GF   1243   1223   111.20   26.84


Title: Re: New Martian220 build - YAW/GYRO issues
Post by: merin_83 on November 09, 2016, 02:05:11 PM
Guys today, i removed the fc mount, and then just kept the build clean, no FPV also, but still its there, then i checked the motor vibration, seems like motor 1 has small vibration and motor 2 has more from the motors tab, attached video of same ...

youtube like of test below

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iPgKDLtmEV8 (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iPgKDLtmEV8)

Please let me know your suggestions


Title: Re: New Martian220 build - YAW/GYRO issues - UPDATE
Post by: merin_83 on November 09, 2016, 07:47:47 PM
Today I removed the X racer 3.1 and mounted 2.1, seems like the yaw noice faded away.... dont seems to exist...

And here is the black box link .. https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B_xCImR-u7L4MmVac3JBSzRNWm8/view?usp=sharing (https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B_xCImR-u7L4MmVac3JBSzRNWm8/view?usp=sharing)

So i guess found the real issue ?



Title: Re: New Martian220 build - YAW/GYRO issues
Post by: merin_83 on November 22, 2016, 07:06:22 PM
Guys, finally am getting a replacement, Kumaran from RCH had worked with Vendor FPVmodal and they agreed to replace the board X Racer 3.1  :hatsoff: thanks RCH


Title: Re: New Martian220 build - YAW/GYRO issues - SOLVED
Post by: merin_83 on November 29, 2016, 06:32:28 PM
Today I got the replacement, it works perfect and no noise, no tuning WoW. Issue solved.


Title: Re: New Martian220 build - YAW/GYRO issues
Post by: kn8alpha on November 30, 2016, 02:23:40 PM
That's great.. I would've suspected the ESC or it's firmware or a bum bearing on motor2, both of which could've been confirmed using a swap test.
Any clues what was wrong with the FC? The gyro chip or something else? Doesn't the motor test from PC bypass the gyro sensor and just control ESCs directly? If thats the case the FC output on motor 2 is somehow bad.


Title: Re: Re: New Martian220 build - YAW/GYRO issues
Post by: merin_83 on December 01, 2016, 10:29:19 AM
That's great.. I would've suspected the ESC or it's firmware or a bum bearing on motor2, both of which could've been confirmed using a swap test.
Any clues what was wrong with the FC? The gyro chip or something else? Doesn't the motor test from PC bypass the gyro sensor and just control ESCs directly? If thats the case the FC output on motor 2 is somehow bad.
I dint suspect esc...  As it flew perfect when fc was swapped...  Dono which part in fc

Sent from my Redmi Note 3 using Tapatalk