|
Title: RC Skills - Evaluation criteria Post by: sushil_anand on February 16, 2010, 09:25:53 PM What is the criteria that one could/should use for evaluation? Admittedly, there is a personal assessment involved, but some guidelines would help. Particularly when the "steps" are fairly wide.
A possible poll on this, if considered worthwhile, Anwar? Title: Re: RC Skills - Evaluation criteria Post by: anwar on February 16, 2010, 09:39:30 PM Sushil bhai - This is a can of worms ;)
I guess we can start by defining "skill". Building skill, flying skill, even attitude skills (like volunteering to help others). Are you looking at any specific one, or a well rounded one that takes into account all of this ? Then comes the weightage of each ! And after that, we need some criteria to put marks against each of these. Yep, this could get interesting ;D Title: Re: RC Skills - Evaluation criteria Post by: vinay on February 16, 2010, 10:07:57 PM Since RC stands for radio control - I would say its more of flying skills.
1)Beginner - Like Trainee/software Engineer - Learning to fly/Crash, learning basic theory and can land w/o crashing at the end. 2)Intermediate - Like Senior Software Engineer/Leads - Able to fly confidently, are able to help Beginners, Ocassional crashes, can design/build/maiden planes easily with very little help from forums/other fellow flyers. 3)Advanced - Managers/Architects/CEOs? - Will fly anything, can do torque rolls with eyes closed :giggle: (that was probably too much to ask). Can build fly anything in their specialization. 4)Ultra Advanced - Tareq?, Oh man, I will own that Heli some day (:|~ http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NfXVnhBvOzU&feature=player_embedded Title: Re: RC Skills - Evaluation criteria Post by: atul_pg on February 16, 2010, 10:26:29 PM Ohh my goddd...I would like to touch tareq's feet..he is insane...
how come I missed this video..thanks for sharing vinay.. Title: Re: RC Skills - Evaluation criteria Post by: gauravag on February 17, 2010, 11:24:16 AM Amazing it really is . True 3D control. What control. No words.
Title: Re: RC Skills - Evaluation criteria Post by: sushil_anand on February 17, 2010, 11:30:49 AM Quote Ohh my goddd...I would like to touch tareq's feet. At Amby Valley, 2008, he put the Tx on the ground and flew a bit with his TOE. That's a bit of his foot/feet you could touch ;D ;D Title: Re: RC Skills - Evaluation criteria Post by: sushil_anand on February 17, 2010, 11:42:11 AM Quote Yep, this could get interesting I hope so! But I think this SHOULD not veer off course into talking about/seeing skilled fliers. Vinay is right in saying it should - primarily - skill in operating radio models, be it cars, aircraft, whatever if "RC skills" is the reference. Though aircraft do come to the fore here. Yes, it could be expanded into (aero)modelling skills. The can of worms could well be used to compost some fertiliser for good growth! Title: Re: RC Skills - Evaluation criteria Post by: anwar on February 17, 2010, 11:50:00 AM So if operating skills are the focus, and aircraft are the first ones to be tackled, the two big schools of thought are pattern and 3D. I am guessing scale flying can be part of patterns.
In that case, it is easy to define a set of maneuvers either way, and how well someone executes them would be one way of categorizing the "RC Skills". Cars can be tackled similarly. I do see serious grounds for people who build more than they fly to object to the name "RC Skills" (as opposed to something like "RC Maneuver Skills" :) ) PS: My can of worms remark was about the wide variety of possibilities that could arise out of such a topic, nothing negative implied ;) Title: Re: RC Skills - Evaluation criteria Post by: sushil_anand on February 17, 2010, 12:18:39 PM Quote PS: My can of worms remark was about the wide variety of possibilities that could arise out of such a topic, nothing negative implied Did not, for even a moment, think so. I was just making a joke. PUN , yes, PUNishment, NO! Title: Re: RC Skills - Evaluation criteria Post by: anwar on February 17, 2010, 04:29:59 PM Still not clear on the objective :headscratch:
Are we trying to just setup a poll, so that people can self evaluate their flying / driving skills ? Or, are you planning to use this in a local group/field so that you can classify people ? Title: Re: RC Skills - Evaluation criteria Post by: Hellyflyer on February 17, 2010, 05:20:16 PM I think the thread started with setting up some guidelines for your self and then get assessed on those by some one. I think we can use IRCHA guidelines they have 8 grades of skill level free to download each level has certain things that you need to perform perfectly to master that level. I think it it can be a good way to assess your self
http://ircha.org/index.php?pr=PPP_Levels Hellyflyer |